Andy Burnham is in Brussels today for his first UK–EU summit, days after telling the country that Brexit has not delivered. He has promised a ‘national conversation’ on Britain’s relationship with the bloc, and has let it be known that applying to rejoin could one day be an option.
But what exactly would Britain be rejoining? One standout part of Burnham’s justification for the new deal was to give “bigger horizons” to British young people and address youth unemployment. But the EU is full of examples of terrible youth unemployment. In Spain, France, Sweden and Finland, more than one in five young people looking for work cannot find it. France alone now has 755,000 unemployed under-25s, more than the whole of Britain, and in Italy fewer than half of people in their twenties have a job at all. Across much of southern Europe, the result is a generation still living with its parents at 30. Is this the future Burnham wants for Britain?
More broadly, people here have a vague sense that things on the Continent are not going well. The most obvious symptom was the enormous outbreak of violence and looting in France, which spread elsewhere to. France saw more than 1,200 protests and riots, more than 6,500 people, most of them minors, were arrested in the first weeks alone, and 24 schools have been burned or ransacked.
But the problems in the EU are much deeper than just ‘France is burning’. The European Union has spent the decade since the referendum becoming less democratic, more hostile to free speech and steadily poorer. That is the club Burnham wants us to rejoin.
Power without voters
Britain voted to leave in large part because people recognised that power was ebbing ever further away from the voters, and that Brussels was both the source of endless undemocratic dictats and an all-too-convinient hiding place for national politicians who were out of ideas, disillusioned with the British nation, and desperate to avoid accountability.
But since 2016, these problems have only intensified. Rather than seeking a renewed democratic mandate, European elites doubled-down on undemocratic instruments to force through their agenda. They have exploited treaty provisions written for emergencies to legislate above the heads of voters. Such chicanery underpinned the €750 billion Covid recovery fund and SAFE, a €150 billion defence loan scheme adopted with MEPs shut out. Even the Socialist group’s legal affairs coordinator accused Ursula von der Leyen of ‘a clear strategy of consolidating power within the EU Executive. Von der Leyen has been furiously battling to amass ever more power in the EU Commission whilst refusing to release her own text messages with Pfizer’s chief executive related to vaccine procurement.
Elections themselves have become negotiable. Romania cancelled one. In Poland, the government is using the police to take over a top court. In France and Germany, the authorities are pursuing the main opposition parties through endless lawfare. Brussels has watched all of this with indifference at best. To many across the continent, the reality is becoming clearer by the day: no election anywhere in the EU can remove the permanent bureaucracy that runs it.
Speech as a security threat
On free speech, the change since 2016 is starkest. The Digital Services Act lets approved ‘trusted flaggers’ press platforms to remove or bury content, and lets the Commission fine those platforms up to 6 per cent of their global turnover. Last December it fined X €120 million – a thinly veiled attack on Elon Musk’s platform simply because it attempts to offer users greater freedom of speech. On top of this sits the European Democracy Shield, unveiled a year ago, with its European Centre for Democratic Resilience, its network of ‘independent’ fact-checkers and its enthusiasm for ‘prebunking’, which means warning citizens off arguments before they have heard them.
What this looks like in practice became clear in July, when at least 60,000 people crossed into Ceuta, a Spanish enclave of 80,000. Our investigation at FSI Europe found that Newtral, the Spanish fact-checker, sent its head of verification to three meetings on Ceuta, including a round table in Brussels with around twenty representatives of EU institutions, platforms and fact-checkers. By its own account, Newtral then flagged more than 70 pieces of content through the rapid-response system of the EU’s Code of Conduct on Disinformation. Its monitoring did not stop at fake videos. It extended to messages about immigration and to what it judged misleading arguments in the political debate.
As Spain prepares to go to the polls to attempt to oust a Prime Minister embroiled in corruption scandals and who presided over a million-plus amnesty of illegal migrants, fact checkers and NGOs are increasingly empowered to regulate what counts as legitimate debate.
Worryingly, this attempt to restrict political alternatives under the guise of combatting “misinformation” and “Russian interference” is something Burnham is already learning from the EU. His National Centre for Information Defence wants to ‘detect, attribute and disrupt’ so-called hostile information attacks, working hand in glove with the intelligence agencies, the police and the social media companies. This initiative is squarely modelled on the EU’s Democracy Shield. In both cases, what is being demonstrated is the desire to create a “shield against democracy”.
A green squeeze on a stalled economy
If the Union is becoming ever less democratic, it is also becoming dangerously hostile to economic growth. The EU’s addiction to green mandates, carbon taxes, and endless regulation is a major driver of this.
Germany, once the engine of Europe, shrank in 2023 and 2024 and grew by just 0.2 per cent in 2025. EY estimates that German industry cut around 124,000 jobs last year, about 50,000 of them in car-making. Since the referendum, Britain’s economy has grown by 14.7 per cent, against 12.6 per cent for France and 8.0 per cent for Germany.
Energy explains much of it. European firms pay two to three times as much for electricity as their American competitors – and the disparity is only growing. Brussels has responded with a raft of measures almost guaranteed to make the problem worse. From 2028, a new carbon price, ETS2, will land on petrol, diesel and home heating across the Union. It was meant to start in 2027 and was pushed back a year for fear of what it would do to household bills. With fuel prices rising again because of the Iran war, several governments want it delayed further. Friedrich Merz has written to von der Leyen to say he rejects ‘further changes’.
The car industry shows the same logic in reverse. Having banned new petrol and diesel cars from 2035, Brussels is now unpicking the ban after carmakers warned it would deepen their crisis. Then there is the rest of the machine: the AI Act, the carbon border levy, and sweeping sustainability reporting and due diligence rules. The Commission is forced into the farcical position of proposing “simplification” rules to partially water down its own regulations, both of which – the regulations and the simplification packages – run into thousands of pages.
The debt story is also hugely worrying. France expects public debt to reach 119.3 per cent of GDP this year, and Paris now pays more to borrow than Rome. The Council’s draft budget would let the Commission borrow up to €350 billion for crisis loans to member states, backed by national treasuries. Brussels is locked in a deadlock over plans to massively increase the EU’s budget when the member states have no budget of their own to spare. The favoured approach in the city is for the EU to acquire special new powers to raise its own taxes.
No wonder that many in the EU are rubbing their hands at the prospect of Britain getting close to the EU. ‘Burnham needs Europe and we need cash,’ says one EU diplomat.
This would get enormously worse if Britain were to fully rejoin. On FSI Europe’s calculation from the Council’s own negotiating box, a returning Britain would pay a net £24–29 billion a year, roughly double its last bill as a member. That is the equivalent of £830 to £1,000 for every household in the country.
More Brexit, not less
Plenty of Leave voters would agree with Mr Burnham that ‘take back control’ was never delivered. But the failure of successive British governments to use the country’s independence is no argument for giving it up. If anything, it is an argument for more Brexit.
Burnham’s case rests on a picture of Europe that is a decade out of date. The European Union of 2026 sidelines its voters, polices what they may say and charges them more for the privilege every year. Britain should not be asking how to get back in. It should be asking how to make sure it never has to.
Jacob Reynolds is an associate fellow of the Academy of Ideas and policy director for Freedom and Sovereignty Initiative Europe (FSI Europe).
At the Battle of Ideas festival last month, a standout discussion featuring Lord David Frost, Dr Norman Lewis, Catherine McBride OBE, Ali Miraj and Steve Wright took a deep look at the EU’s economic malaise
For more analysis of how Brexit has been betrayed, watch Claire Fox join a host of key figures in Spiked’s film Brexit: A revolution betrayed?


